Title of Invention

A CATALYST BASED ON ZEOLITE CRYSTALLITES ATTACHED TO SUPPORT

Abstract A catalyst system based on zeolite crystallites attached to support or incorporated in a matrix and a catalytically active compound incorporated in the zeolite, the said crystallites having a diameter or between 20 and 300 nm and said catalytically active component having a formula selected from: CoMn2(O)(R-COO)6 L1k1 L2k2 wherein : R is an optionally substituted C1-C4 alkyl; L1 is an optionally substituted nitrogen containing carboxylic acid or carboxylate; L2 is selected from the group consisting of H2O, an optionally substituted C1-C4 alkyl containing carboxylic acid, an optionally substituted C5-C6 cycloalkyl or heterocycle, an optionally substituted C5-C6 heteroaryl or aryl; and k1+k2 = 3; wherein the zeolite has an Si/AI atomic ratio of at least 8.
Full Text WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/000876
Title: Catalyst and method for preparing aromatic caxboxylic acids
FIELD OF THE INVENTION
[0001] The present invention relates generally to the field of process
chemistry. More in particular the invention pertains to novel catalysts useful
in the preparation of aromatic carboxylic acids and to a method, for preparing
aromatic carboxylic acids.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0002] Aromatic carboxylic acids, such as benzoic acid, phthalic acid,
terephthalic acid, trimethyl benzoic acids, naphthalene dicarbosylic acids and
the like, are used widely as intermediates in the chemical industry. Aromatic
carboxylic acids are prepared by oxidation of their corresponding alkyl
aromatic compounds (see Suresh, A., "Engineering Aspects of Industrial
Liquid-Phase Air Oxidation of Hydrocarbons," Ind. Eng. Chem., Vol. 39: p.
3958-3997, (2000)). For instance, terephthalic acid is prepared by oxidation of
p-xylene, as shown in the schematic below:

[0003] Terephthalic acid, TPA (1, 4- benzenedicarboxylic acid), is of
commercial interest to the polymer industry because of its use in the
manufacture of saturated polyesters, such as polyethylene terephthalate
(PET), 1, 2-othemediol, and copolymere thereof. Worldwide psoduction of of TPA
and its corresponding dimethyl ester, dimethyl terephthalate, ranked about
25th in tonnage of all chemicals produced in 1992, and about 10th of all organic
chemicals.

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/000876
2
[0004] As shown in the scheme below, the oxidation of p-xylene is a radical
initiated, step-wise reaction which, produces two main intermediates, p-toluic
acid and 4-formyl-benzoic acid.

[0005] Incomplete oxidation of 4-formyl-benzoic acid (4-CBA) leads to
contamination of TPA purity. Removal of 4-CBA is complicated by the fact
that it co-crystallizes with TPA due to its structural similarity with TPA.
Contamination with 4-CBA can be substantial; for instance, there are
production processes that yield a TPA stock which have approximately 5000
ppm of 4-CBA (Perniconea et al., "An investigation on Pd/C industrial catalysts
for the purification of terephthalic add," Catalysis Today, Vol. 44: p. 129-185
(1998)). Thus, subsequent purification steps after TPA production are often
necessary in order to attain TPA feedstock of sufficient purity for high-grade
polyester synthesis (see Matsuzawa, K. et al., "Technological Development of
Purified Terephthalic Acid," Chemical Economy & Engineering Review, Vol. 8
(9): p. 25-30 (1976)).
[0006] There are numerous process methods available for manufacturing
TPA, each of which have varying production and purity yields for TPA. Most
of these processes involve oxidation, of p-xylene with an oxygen source e.g. air
or O2 gas, in the presence of liquid phase, homogeneous catalysts containing at
least cobalt and/or manganese metals. In addition, most of these processes are
conducted in the presence of an acidic solvent, such as acetic acid, and as a
rule employ corrosive bromine promoters as a radical source e.g. HBr, NaEr, or

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/000876
3
other metal bromines. Thus, these processes are typically conducted in
expensive, titanium-clad reactors that can accommodate such harsh reaction
conditions. Representative methods for manufacturing TPA are described in
the following patents and publications, the disclosures of all of which are
incorporated herein by reference.
[00071 U.S. Patent. Nos. 2,833,816 and 3,089,906 report a process for
oxidizing a polyalkyl aromatic compound with O2 in acetic acid solvent using a
metal bromine catalyst.
[0008] U.S. Patent No. 4,786,753 reports a process for oxidizing di- and
trimethyl benzenes in the presence of an aliphatic acid in the presence of a
nickel, zirconium, and manganese catalyst system with a bromine source.
[0009] U.S. Patent No. 4,877,900 report a two-stage oxidation process for p-
xylene with molecular oxygen in the presence of a heavy metal catalyst and
bromine, wherein the second stage involves post-oxidation with molecular
oxygen and is conducted at a higher temperature then the first stage.
[0010] U.S. Patent No, 4,892,970 reports a two-stage process for the
oxidation of alkyl benzenes in the presence of a cobalt, nickel, or zirconium
metal catalyst and bromine, wherein additional bromine is added to a second
stage of the process.
[001 l] U.S. Patent No. 5,453,538 reports a process for oxidizing dimethyl
benzene with molecular oxygen in a C1-C6 aliphatic carboxylic acid solvent
with a cobalt, manganese, and cerium catalyst and a bromine source.
[0012] U.S. Patent Nos. 5,596,129 and 5,696,285 reports a process for
oxidizing alkyl benzenes by supplying a nearly pure O2 gas source to the
reactor. These processes are conducted in an acetic acid/water medium and
utilizes a cobalt, manganese, and bromine catalyst.

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/000876
4
[0013] Cincotti, A. et al. ("Kinetics and related engineering aspects of
catalytic liquid-phase oxidation of p-xylene to terephthalic acid," Catalysis
Today, Vol. 52; p. 881-347, (1999)) reports a kinetic model for TPA production.
This study evaluated the oxidation of p-xylene in a methyl benzoate solvent
using cobalt naphthenate as a catalyst. P-tolualdehyde was used as a
promoter source and either pure oxygen or air was the oxidation source.
[0014] Dunn, J. et al. ('Terephthalie Add Synthesis in High-Temperature
Liquid Water, Ind. Eng. Chera, Bee., Vol. 41: p. 4460-4465, (2002)) reports a
TPA synthesis process in liquid water at temperatures ranging from 250 to 300
°C. This process utilises hydrogen peroxide, instead of air or O2, as an oxidant.
The following catalysts were evaluated in the study: manganese bromide,
cobalt bromide, manganese acetate, nickel bromide, hafnium bromide, and
zirconium bromide.
[0015] Partenheixer, W. et al., ("The effect of zirconium in metal/bromide
catalysts during the autoxidation of p-xylene," Journal of Molecular Catalysis
A: Chemical, Vol. 206: p. 105-119, (2003)) reports the oxidation of p-xylene in
acetic acid medium with a zirconium catalyst and either a cobalt,
manganese/bromide, nickel/manganese/bromide, or cobalt/manganese/bromide
catalyst.
[0016] The less corrosive bromoanthracenes, in comparison to NaBr or HBr,
have been employed as a bromide source in the oxidation of p-xylene. Saha et
al. ("Bromoanthracenes and metal co-catalyste for the autoxidation of para-
xylene," Journal of Molecular Catalysis A: Chemical, Vol. 207: p. 121-127,
(2004)) reports the oxidation of p-xylene in acetic acid using 9,10-
dibromoanthracene or 9-bromoanthracene in, the presence of Co(OAc)s and
either a Mn(OAc)2, Ce(OAc)3, or ZrOCl2 co-catalyst.
[0017] Methods for TPA manufacturing that use solid catalysts include
Chavan et al. ("Selective Oxidation of para-Xylene to Terephthalic Acid by us-

WO 2006/068471 PCT/Nl,2003/0©087
5
oxo-bridged Oo/Mn Cluster Complexes Encapsulated in Zeolite-Y," Joiwnal of
Catalysis, Vol. 24: p. 409-419, (2001)) and Sriniv&s et al (U,S. Patent No.
6,649,791 and U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2003/0008770). In
these methods, solid catalysts of ug-oxo-bridged Co/Mn cluster complexes,
[Co3(O)(CHsCOO)e(pyridine)3]+! |Mn8(O)(CH»COO)e(pyridine)83+, and
CoMu2(O)(CIIaCOO)e(pyTidine)s, are encapsulated in Zeolito-Y an,d the
ojddation process was carried out in an acetic acid/water solvent using NaBr as
a radical initiator.
(0018] TPA has also been prepared employing a solid catalyst without the
use of bromide ions. Jacob et al, (Journal Applied Catalysis A: General, Vol.
T82: p. 91-96, (1999)) described the aerial oxidation of p-xylene over Zeolite-
encapsulated salen, saltin, and salcyhexen complexes of cobalt or manganese
using t-butyl hydroperoxide as the initiator. This process converts up to 50-
60% of p-xylene; however, the yields of TPA are low and the main product
attained is p-toluic acid.
(00191 Currently, there exists a need for methods of synthesizing aromatic
carboxylic acids with 3t*f3icicnt]y high yields and suitable p*irity fo*
subsequent high-grade manufacturing processes, so as to obviate the need for
additional purification steps. In addition, there exists a need for methods that
avoid the use of corrosive feed materials or other process materials which may
be harmful to the environment, such as acetic acid, NaBr, or HBr.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0020] The present invention concerns novel solid catalysts, and their use in
the preparation of an aromatic carboxylic acid by oxidation of an alkyl
aromatic compound. The invention also provides a one-step method using such
a catalyst, which circumvents the need for subsequent purification procedures
e.g. hydrogenation, for the preparation of high-grade alfcyl aromatic
cotQpoutJids. Embodiments of the present, mat/hod avoid f.hfl use af nnrrosive

WO 2006/068471 ( PCT/NL2005/000876
6
inorganic bromine reagents by employing more environmentally sensible
organic bfomated reagents. The novel catalyst itself consists of small
crystallites of the catalytic principle, with a specified narrow size distribution,
which are attached to or encapsulated in a support, more in particular
encapsulated within a tneso-porous, possibly functionally enhanced matrix
material.
The present invention is drawn to a catalytic principle based on zeolite
crystallites attached to support or incorporated in a matrix and a catalytically
active principle incorporated in the zeolite, the*, aaid crystallites having a
diameter of between 20 and 300 nm and said catalytically active principle
having a formula corresponding to:
CoMn2(0)(R-COO)6Liki IA2 wherein:
R is an optionally substituted C1-C4 alkyl;
Ll is tun upliyju&Uly substituted nitrogen containing carboxylic acid
or salts thereof;
L2 is selected from the group consisting of H2O, an optionally
substituted C&-C4 alkyl containing carboxylic acid, an
optionally substituted Cs-C optionally substituted C5-C$ heteroaryl or aryl; and
kl + k2 = 3;
wherein the zeolite has an Si/Al atomic ratio of at least 8.
Embodiments include catalysts of the above formula where R is -CH3 or -CzHr>;
where L1 is picolinic acid, nicotinic acid, or iso-nicotinic acid; and where L2 is
CH3OOOH or H2O.

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/00087r>
7
[0021] The present invention is also drawn to a catalytic principle having a
formula corresponding to CoMnz(O)(R-COO)6 k3 IAS L4k4f wherein:
R is an optionally substituted C1-C4 aJLkyl;
L3 i« an. optionally substituted nitrogen nontnirnng r.arboxylate;
L4 is selected from the group consisting of IfcO, an optionally
substituted nitrogen containing carboxylic acid, an optionally
substituted CVd alkyl containing carboxyhc acid, an optionally
substituted CG-CG cycloalkyl or heterocycle, and an optionally
substituted Cr,-Ce heteroaryl or aryl;
k3 is 1, 2, or 3; and
k3 + k4=3.
{0022] Preferred embodiments include catalytic principles of the above
formula where R is -CHs or -C2H1;; where L5 is 1-pyridine-COO, 2-pyridine-
COO-, or 3-pyridin©-COO"; and where 1A is picolinic acid, nicotinic acid, i-
nicotinic acid, CHsCOOH, or H2O .
[0023] The invention resides therein, that the specific catalytically active
principle is incorporated within the specifically selected zeolite, which zeolite
is preferably characterized in that it has an Si/Al atomic ratio of at least 8.
Preferably the ratio is at most 12. Preferably the size of the channels is such,
that the catalytically active principle is too large to migrate through the
channels. However, the crossings of the channels are sufficiently large to trap
the catalytically active principle. In the invention the said principle is
accordingly synthesized in place, i.e. at said crossings, which is the preferred

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/000876
8
method, although it is also possible that the zeolite is synthesized around the
said complete principle.
[0024] Suitable channel diameters arc within the range of up to 8 A.
[0025] The zeolite crystallites are quite small, namely between 20 and 300
nm, With larger crystallites diffusion limitation may occur, resulting in
decrease of activity ajad selectivity, thereby defeating one of the objects of the
inveatioa, n&moly the possibility to produce aromatic earboxylic acids, such as
therephtalic acids without the need to have subsequent purification.
10026] Another aspect, of the invention resides in the matrix encapsulation,
Thiw matrix supports the crystallites and may have a waseo-potfous structure.
The support or matrix material should preferably have no or limited
functionality in the oxidation reaction, and be such that it does not hinder the
diffusion of reaction components into or out of the crystallites. Suitable matrix
materials include mesoporous silica, carbon, carbon nanotubes and the like,
[0027] Catalytic principles presented herein have the metal complex hosted
within a possibly functionally enhanced zeolite, which include, but are not
limited to MEI, beta (*BEA), and also including members of the associated
disorder families, such as fibrous and the like, micro-porous structures based
on the above zeolites and mixtures thereof. For a detailed explanation of the
structural similarities among zeolites and a list of references with specific
structural information about zeolites, see, for example, U.S. Patent Nos.
4,344,851; 4,503,023; 4,840,779; and Baerlocher et al, "Atlas of Zeolite
Framework Types," ELSEVTER Fifth Revised Edition, (2001)). Preferred
zeolites used to host the presented metal complexes include beta zeolite.
[00281 The phrase "alkyl" refers to hydrocarbyl groups comprising from 1 to
20 carbon atoms. The phrase "alkyl" includes straight chain alkyl groups such
as methyl, ethyl, propyl, and the like. The phrase also includes branched

ft'O 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/000876
9
chain isomers of straight chain alkyl groups. Additionally, alkyl groups can be
optionally substituted according to the definition below. Thus, alkyl groups
includes primary alkyi groups, secondary alkyl groups, and tertiary alkyl
groups. Presently, preferred alkyl groups include unsubstituted alkyl groups ;
having from 1 to 4 carbon, atoms while even more preferred such groups have (
from 1 to 3 carbon atoms. I
i
[00291 The phrase "substituted" refers to an. atom or group of atoms that :
has been replaced with another substituent The phrase "substituted" includes
any level of substitution, i.e. mono-, di-, tri-, tetra-, or penta-subetitution,
where such substitution is chemically permissible. Substitutions can occur at
any chemically accessible position and on any atom, such as substitution^) on :
carbons. For example, substituted compound are those where one or more ;
bonds to a hydrogen or carbon atom(s) contained therein are replaced by a i
bond to non-hydrogen and/or non-carbon atom(s).
{0030] The phrase "nitrogen containing carboxylic acid" refers to a
compound comprising at least on© carboxylic acid moiety (-COOH) and at least
on© optionally substituted nitrogen atom. Nitrogen, containing carboxylic acid
compounds embrace acyclic and cyclic structures, wherein the nitrogen can
optionally be a ring member. For instance, nitrogen containing carboxylic acid
encompass pyridines, picolines, pyrimidines, piperidines, and the like that
comprise at least one -COOH. Preferable nitrogen containing carboxylic acids
include picolinic acid, nicotinic acid, and i-nicotinic (the structures of which are
shown below).


WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/O00S76
10
[0031] The phrase "C1-C4 alkyl containing carboxylic acid" refers to a
compound comprising at least one carboxylic acid moiety (-COQR) and at least
one optionally substituted Ci-C4 alky! group. The phrase embraces straight
chain, branched, and cyclic C1-C4 alkyl groups comprising at least on© -COOH.
Furthermore, the phrase also embraces Ci-C4 alkyl groups containing any level
of saturation. For instance, C1-C4 alkyl containing carboxylic acid compounds
encompass acetic acid, propionic acid, butyric acid, and halogenated
substitutions thereof, such as CHgFCOOK, CHBCICOOH, CHaBrCOOH, and
the like. Preferable CVC4 alkyl containing carboxylie acid include OH3COOH.
f0032] The phrase "nitrogen containing carboxylate' refers to a compound
comprising at least one carboxylate moiety (-COO) and at least one optionally
substituted nitrogen atom. Nitrogen containing carboxylate compounds
embrace acyclic and cyclic structures, wherein th© nitrogen can optionally be a
ring member. For instance, nitrogen containing carboxylates encompass
pyridines , picolines, pyrimidines, piperidines, morpholine and the hke that
comprise at least on« -COO . Preferable nitrogen containing carbosylatee
include 1-pyridine-COG', 2-pyridine-COO-, and 3-pyridine-COO- (the
structures of which are shown below).

[0033] The phrase "cycloalkyl" refers to a saturated or unsaturated alicyclic
moiety having 1 to 20 carbon atoms. Cycloalkyl groups include cyclohexyl and
cycloheptyi. Th© phrase "substituted cycloalkyl" refers to a cycloalkyl group
that is substituted according to the definition provided above. Substituted
cycloalkyl groups can have one or more atom substituted with straight or
branched chain alkyl groups and can further comprise cycloalkyl groups that

WO 2006/068471 . PCT/NL2005/000876
11
are substituted with other rings including fused rings. Representative
substituted cycloalkyl groups may be mono-substituted such as, but not
limited to 2-, 3», 4-, 5-substituted cyclohexyl groups or mono-substituted
groups, such as alkyl or halo groups
(0034] The phrase "heterocyde" or "heterocyclic" refers to both aromatic and
nonaromatie ring hydrocarbyl compounds. Heterocyclic groups include
monocyclic, and bicyclic compounds contairir.g 3 or more ring wpmhers.al -
which one or more is a heteroatom such as, but not limited to, N and O.
Examples of heterocyclyl groups include, but are not limited to, unsaturated 3
to 6 cumbered rings containing 1 to 3 nitrogen atoms such as, but not limited
to pyrrolyl, pyrrolinyl, imidazolyl, pyrazolyl, pyxidyl, dihydropyridyl,
pyximidyl, pyxstzinyl, pyridasrinyl, triazolyl (e.g. 4H-l,2,4-triazolyl, 1H-1,2,3-
triazolyl, and 2H-l,2,3-triazolyl); saturated 3 to 8 membered rings containing 1
to 4 nitrogen atoms such as, but not limited to, pyxrolidinyl, iraidasKolidinyl,
piperidinyl, piperazinyl; condensed unsatuvated heterocyclic groups containing
1 to 3 nitrogen atoms such as, but not limited to, indolyl, isoindolyl, indoiinyl,
indolizinyl, benzimidazolyl, quinolyl, isoquinolyl, indawlyl, benzotriazolyl;
unsaturated 3 to 8 membered rings containing 1 to 2 oxygen atoms and 1 to 3
nitrogen atoms such as, but not limited to, oxazolyl, ieoxaziolyl, oxadiazolyl (e.g.
1,2,4-oxadiaaolyl, l.,3,4-oxadiat?olyl, and 1,2,5-oxadiazolyi); saturated 3 to 8
membered rings containing 1 to 2 oxygen atoms and 1 to 3 nitrogen atoms such
as, but not limited to, morpholinyl; unsaturated condensed heterocyclic groups
containing 1 to 2 oxygen atoms and 1 to 3 nitrogen atoms, for example,
benzoxazolyl, benzoxadiazolyl, and benzoxavonyl (e.g. 2H-l,4-benzoxa2iinyl).
Preferred heterocyclyl groups contain 5 or 6 ring members. More preferred
heterocyclyl groups include morpholine, piperazine, piperidine, pyrrolidine,
iroidazole, pyrazole, l,l£,3-triasjole, 1,2,4-triazoIe, tetrazole, thiomorphoUne,
thiomorpholine in which the S atom of the thiomorpholine is bonded to one or
more O atoms, pyrrole, homopiperazine, oxazolidin-2-one, pyrrolidin-2-one,

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/00087G
12
oxazole, quinuclidine, thiasole, andisoxazole. The phrase "substituted
heteroeycle" OT "substituted heterocyclic" refers to a heterocycHe group that is
substituted according to the definition provided above. Examples of
substituted heteroeyclic groups include, but arc aot limited to, 2-
raethylbenziiaidazolyl, 5»methyibenzimidazoly!f 1-methyl piperazinyl, 2-
chloropyridyl, and the like.
[0035} The phrase "aryl" refers to aromatic radicals comprising from 3 to 20
carbon atoms. Aryl groups include, but are not limited to, phenyl, biphenyl,
anthracenyl, and naphthenyl. The phrase "substituted aryl group" refers to an
aryl group that ie substituted according to the definition provided above. For
example, substituted aryl groups may be bonded to one or more carbon
atom(s), oxygen atom(s), or nitrogen atom(s), and also includes aryl groups in
which one or more aromatic carbons of the aryl group is bonded to a
substituted and/or unsubstituted alkyl, alkenyl, or alkynyl group. This
includes bonding arrangements in which two carbon atoms of an aryl group
are bonded to two atoms of an alfcyl, alkenyl, or alkynyl group to define a fused
ring system (e.g. dihydronaphthyl or tetrahydronaphthyl). Thus, the phrase
"substituted aryl" includes, but is not limited.to tolyl, and hydroxyphenyl
among others. Preferably, aromatic groups are substituted with alkyl,
earboxylic acid (-OOOH), and/or carboxylate groups (-COO).
[0036] The phrase "heteroaryl" refers to a 3 to 20-membered aromatic ring
consisting of carbon atoms and heteroatoms, such as N and and O or (ii) an 8-
to 10-membered bicyclic or polycydic ring system, consisting of carbon atoms
and heteroatoms, such as N and O, wherein at least one of the rings in the
bicyclic system is an aromatic ring. The heteroaxyl ring may be attached at
any heteroatom or carbon atom. Representative heteroaryl compounds
include, for example, pyridyl, pyrazinyl, pyrimidinyl, pyridooxazolyl,
pyxidazooxazolyl, and pyrimidooxazolyl. The phrase "substituted heteroaryl"

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/000876
13
refers to a heterparyl group that is substituted according to the definition
provided above.
[0037J An aspect of the invention is drawn to methods ox manufacturing
processes for the preparation of an aromatic carboxylic acid by contacting an
alkyl aromatic compound with an oxygen source in the presence of a catalyst
as provided herein. Preferably, such methods are performed in the presence of
a solvent in. which said aromatic carboxylic acid is soluble.
[003S| The present invention is also drawn to a one-Step process for
preparing an aromatic carboxylio acid comprising: contacting an aJfcyl aromatic
compound with an oj^gen source in the presence of a catalyst as provided
herein. Such one-step proceasea are highly efficient, thus circumventing the
need for subsequent purification procedures e.g. hydrogenation or
crystallization, in the preparation of high-grade alkyl aromatic compounds.
[0039] Preferably, the present methods are directed to the preparation of
terephthalic acid by oxidizing p-xylene in the presence of a catalyst provided
herein. Other aromatic carboxylic acids which may be prepared include iso-
terephthalic acid and naphthalene carboxylic acid.
J0O4GJ The phrase "aromatic carboxylic acid" refers to any optionally
substituted aromatic group that comprises at least one carboxylic acid (-
COOH) substituent. Representative aromatic carboxylic acids include, but axe
not limited to, benzoie acid, isophthabc acid, phthalic acid, terephthalic acid,
trimsthyl benzoic acids, naphthalene dicarboxylio acids, and the Uke.
Preferred aromatic carboxylic acids include terephthalic acid (TPA).
[0041] The phrase "alkyl aromatic" refers to any optionally substituted
aromatic group, as defined above, comprising at least one optionally
substituted aliyl group, as defined above. Representative alkyl aromatic
compounds include, but are not limited to, toluene, xylene (p-xylene), triraethyl

WO 2000/068471 PCT/INL2005/000876
14
benzene, methylnaphthalene, dimethylnaphthalene, and the like. Preferred
alkyl aromatic compounds include p-xylene.
[0042J The phrase "oxygen source" refers to any source which supplies
oxygen directly or indirectly in the presently claimed method. An oxygen
source may be fed from an external source or generated in situ. Preferably, an
oxygen source is provided in the same phase as the solvent. For instance, O2
may be provided to p-xylene liquid solvent by absorption from a supercritical
solvent saturated in oxygen, from gaseous oxygen at elevated pressure through
a selective membrane. Alternatively, Og may absorbed into a solvent by
absorption out of an oxygen containing gas at high pressure, such as air or
molecular oxygen, and fed directly into the reactor and/or to a recycled stream
from the reactor by diffusion through a selective membrane. Gaseous Og may
also be provided by evaporation or dissolution of liquid oxygen and absorption
into a solvent, including supercritical fluids, and fed into the reactor medium
from a saturated solution directly or indirectly, depending on the
characteristics of the oxygen solvent. Representative oxygen sources include,
but are not limited to, air, gaseous and liquid molecular oxygen, hydrogen,
peroxide, and the like. Preferably, oxygen sources used herein comprise at
least 99% oxygen, at least 95%, at least 90%, at least 85%, or at least 80%
oxygen.
[0043] Embodiments of the invention relate to methods of preparing
aromatic carboxylic acids in the presence of a solvent in which said aromatic
carboxylic acid is soluble. Preferably, the solvent used in the present methods
is the same as the alkyl aromatic compound. For example, in embodiments
drawn to methods for preparing TPA, it is preferred that both the solventaM
the alkyl aromatic compound is p-xylene,
[0044] Preferable embodiments include performing the present methods in
the absence of an, acidic solvent. Acidie solvents, such as acetie acid, are highly

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/000876
16
corrosive and thus, steel-clad reactors are currently being used to
accommodate reactions employing said solvents. Methods presented herein
provide an improvement over the art, in part, avoid the use of steel-clad
reactors by performing the reactions in a non-acidic solvent.
[0045] The phrase "solvent" refers to a substance, usually a liquid, which is
capable of dissolving another substance, such as an alkyl aromatic compound.
Solvents used herein have a purity of at least 99%, of at least 97%, or of at
least 95%. Preferred solvents for the present methods include p-xylene.
[00461 The phrase "soluble" refers to solubility of a given compound, such as
the produced aromatic carboxylic acid, in a solvent. Solubility can be
measured in units of g/L or moles/L, wherein such measurements are taken at
temperatures ranging from 150°C to 250°C and at pressures ranging from 20
atm to 50 atm. I» a preferred embodiment, the solubility of terephthalic acid
in p-xylen? at 25gC and latm is 0.0028 g/L.
[0047] The phrase "acidic" refers to solvents or solutions hsiving a pH lower
than 7, such as 5 or lower, and further such as 3 or lower.
{0048] The reaction rate of methods of producing aromatic carboxylic acids
using an invention catalyst can be accelerated by the addition of a halogen
containing agent. The phrase "halogen containing agent" refers to an organic
or inorganic agent which comprises a halogen ion, such as F, Cl, Br, and I.
Preferable halogen containing agents are capable of mediating radical
formation and hydrogen abstraction without explicit involvement of free
halogen radicals or ions such as P», F-, Cl#, C1-, Br*, or Br. Exemplary halogen
containing agents include hydrocarbyl bromated agents, such as
bromobenzene, S-bromoanthracene, and 9,10-dibromoanthracene.
[0fl49) The phrase "hydrocarbyl" refers to any organic radical having a
directly attachable carbon atom. Hydrocarbyl groups include saturated and

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/000876
16
unsaturated hydrocarbons, straight and branched chain aliphatic
liyArocorboxxo, cyclic kyr)fooarh Representative hydrocarbyl groups include alkyis, alkenyls, a&yxiyls,
cycloalkyb, aryls (such as anthracene), and arylalkyls.
BRIEF DESCKIPTION OF THE DKAWINGS
(0050] FIG. 1 and FIG. 2 are a schematic depicting an exemplary method
for oxidation of alkyi aromatic compounds. Further details regarding the
oxidation of p xylcn.© to produce terepHthalie acid is provided in the Examples
below.
[0051] FIG. 3 details the solubility range of the terephthalic acid and the
operational concentration range of the catalyst.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE XNVEfcfTION
I. INVENTION CATALYSTS
A. PREPARATION OF INVENTION CATALYTIC PRINCIPLE
(00521 The present invention provides novel compositions that have unique
catalytic function by stabilizing a catalytic principle corresponding to
CoMn2(O)(R-COO)6 IAI h\t and CoMn2(O)(K,-COO)e k3 L3k3 L4k4, as described
above, in micro-porous zeolite or as clustered aggregates encapsulated by
specific synthesis within a zeolite composite structure. The catalyst consists of
crystallites of zeolite of appropriate small size embedded in a meso-porous
matrix of inert material or attached to a suitable support.

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NU005/000876
17
Preferred ejoibodiiaeat3 of metal complex of the catalysts provided herein
include CoMa2(O)(CH3-COO)e ^-NCeHUCOOH)? and CoMn2(O)(CH3-COOMl-
NC6H4COO)(l-NCeH4COOH)2 / beta Zeolite with small crystallites in a xneso-porous SiC matrix.
[0053] Various methods for preparing the components for the presented
catalysts are well known to one of skill in the art. For instance, preparative
procedures for synthesizing the catalytic principle of the invention catalyst,
include those described, for example, in Kennet J. et al, ("Applicable Zeolite
Encapsulation Methods Flexible Ligand Method", J. Indus. Phenom., Vol.
21:169-184 (1995)); Vandermade, A. W. et aL (J. Ohem. Soc. Chem, Commun.,
Vol. 1204 (1983)); and Viswanathan et al. (J. Energy Heat and Mass Transfer,
Vol. 8: 281 (1996)). The production of raeso-porous zeolite has been reviewed, i
for example, in Walter G. Klemperer et al. ('Tailored Porous Materials" Chem. j
Mater. 1999, 11, 2633-2656).
Alternative preparative procedures may be employed for preparing zeolites for
use with larger Hgands. In instances where the coordinating molecule is large
or too inflexible to penetrate the zeolite, the zeolite can be synthesized around
the already pre-formed p-3-oxo bridged metal coordinated complex by the use of
structure directing molecules. Such procedures are described, for example, in
Mitchell M. et al. (Z. Phys. B, Vol. 97: 353 (1995)); Lobo, R. et al. (J. Inclusion
Phenom. Mol. Recognit. Chem., Vol. 21: 47 (1995)); and Barton, T. J. et al,
("Tailored Porous Materials", Ohem. Mater., Vol. 11: 2633-2656 (1999)). A
recent review may be found, for example, in Martin P. Attfield ("Microporous
materials" Science Progress (2002), 85 (4), 319-345).
[0054] In addition, the composition of the invention further includes a
zeolite. In preferred embodiments, invention catalysts consist of encapsulated
crystallites of a zeolite catalytic principle. Certain zeolites provide catalytic
principles that may be more optimal for use in the presently claimed methods.

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/00087f,
18
Suitable zeolites for use in the invention have an Si/Al atomic ratio of at least
8. These zeolites are micro-porous materials which comprise pore sixes of up to
8A, and preferably having no zeolite cages.
Preferred zeolites are meso-porous beta zeolite (*BEA) with small, crystallite
size of about 20-200 am but also including members of the associated disorder
families, such as fibrous. Specific embodiments of clustered sites catalysts
provided herein include CoMns(O)(CH3-COO)s (2-NCeH4COOH)s encapsulated
in a beta zeolite which is embedded within a meso-porous S1O2 matrix and
CoMn*(0)(CH*-COO)5 (l-NCe^COOXl-NCsHUCOOH)* hosted in a beta zeolite
supported on meso-porous carbon.
10055J A representative method for encapsulating the invention catalytic
principle involves creating the "ship-in-bottte" catalytic structure by the
"flexible Hgand method". This well known method involves ligand diffusion
through the poree of an already metal exchanged zeolite. For more detailed
discussion of exemplary preparation methods, see, for example Raja et al.,
J.Oattd. Vol. 170, p. 244 (1997); Subbarao et al.. Chem.Comm., Vol. 355,
(1997); andBalkus et al., J. Indus. Phenom., Vol. 21: p. 159 (1995),
B. MATRIX ENCAPSULATION OF INVENTION CATALYSTS
(00561 The embedding of small crystallites of zeolites into a meso-porous
inert matrix in situ during its synthesis is discussed, for example, in
J.C.Jansen et al. (Chem.Commun., p.713 (2001)), in Z.Shan et al. (Chem. EUJ.
J., 7, p.1437 (2001)), in J. C. Jansen et al. (Micro. Meso. Mater., 21, p.213
(1998)) in S. Basso, J. P. Tessonnier, C. Pham-Huu, M. J. Ledoux, French
Patent Appl. No. 02-00541 (2002).
[0057J The encapsulation provides mechanical strength to the catalytic
principle and allows the preparation of the invention catalyst in several

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/000876
19
different forms for use in fixed bed, slurry particles^ membranes and other
configurations.
[0058J The preferred method will depend both on the zeolite component of
the catalytic principle aad the encapsulation matrix material. Preparation
methods may consist of grafting separately prepared zeolites on the inert
matrix material or, alternatively, the composite may be synthesized in situ by
adding the appropriate matrix material to a specific zeolite synthesis gel.
These methods, such as adapted hydrothermal syntheses are generally known
to one skilled in the art. The methodology for synthesis of composites, such as
through the hydrothermal process are discussed, for example, in Oamblor M.
A. et al. ('Characterization of nanocrystallin© zeolite Beta", Microporous and
Mesoporous Materials 25, p. 59-74 (1998)). Synthesis o.f zeolite Y encapsulated
on SiC is discussed, for example, in G.Clet, J.C.Jansfen and H. van. Bekkum,
(poster at 12th IZC, Baltimore, (1998)), whereas grafting of beta zeolite on SiC
is discussed, for example, by S. Feng and T. Bein, (Nature, 368, p.834 (1994)).
M.V. Depositing zeolite crystallites on SiO2 is discussed, for example, in
Landau, N. Zaharur, M. Herskowitz, (Appl. Catal, 115, L7-L14 (1994)). A
procedure to deposit zeolites on carbon is discussed, for example, in C. Madsen,
C.J.H. Jacobsen, (Chem. Comraun. 8, p. 673-674 (1999)). Syntheses of highly
ordered meso-porous structures by means of the self-assembly of pre-formed
clusters of zeolite nuclei in which surfactant micelles templates are used have
been described, for example, in Z. T. Zhang, Y. Han, L, Zhu, R. W. Wang, Y.
Yu, S. L. Qiu, D. Y. Zhao, F. S. Xiao, (Angew. Chem., 113,12-98 - 1301 (2001))
and W. P. Ouo, L. M. Huang, P. Deng, Z. Y. Xue, Q. Z. Li, (Microporous
Mesoporous Mater., 44, 427 - 434 (2001)).
[0059] Preferred encapsulating matrix materials include mesoporous silica
and carbon, such as carbon nanotubes, and SiC,

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2O()5/0O087(5
20
[0060} The ki-situ synthesis of the metal complex itself may be realized
after the encapsulation of the zeolite in the matrix material. The preferred
method for the preparation of the invention catalysts is to create the catalytic
principle itself in the matrix as a second production step after encapsulation.
II. USE OF INVENTION CATALYSTS
[0061] Catalysts provided herein can be employed in a variety of synthetic
processes. For instance, invention catalysts can be used in the synthesis of a
variety of organic compounds, such as, but not limited to, aUkyl, alkenyl,
alkynyl, cyeloalkyl, heterocyclyi, aryl, or heteroaryl containing compounds.
Furthermore, invention catalysts may be used in the stereoselective synthesis
of organic compounds. Moreover, invention catalysts may be utilized in the
preparation of macrocyclie compounds, such as fungicides, antibiotics, natural
product mimetics, and the like.
[00621 Preferably, invention catalysts are used in the oxidation of aikyl
aromatic compounds to produce aromatic caiboxylic acids. Various methods
for oxidizing aikyl aromatic compounds in the presence of a catalyst are well
known to one of skill in the art. Described in the Examples below is a
generalized representative procedure, which can vary within the scope of
routine experimentation and depending on well-known factors, such as seal© of
synthesis,
[0063] The preparation, of aromatic carboxylic acids can be performed in one
reactor or a series of reactor. The phrase "reactor" refers to any vessel
appropriate for accommodating the oxidation reaction described herein. For
example, oxidation of aikyl aromatic compounds can be performed in a single
layge stirred tank reactor. Alternatively, oxidation of aUkyJ, aromatic
compounds can, be performed in a continuous series of reactors. For instance,

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2O05/OOO876
21
an oxygen source can. be provided to each reactor in the series, so as to
facilitate highly efficient oxidation of alkyl aromatic compounds. Additionally,
reactor series can be lock adjusted, so as to prevent backflow of materials.
[0064] Representative reactors which can be used in accordance with
methods provided herein include titatnum-clad and steel reactors.
{0065] The present methods for the preparation of aromatic carboxylic acids
can, be conducted at temperatures ranging from 200 to 250 "C, and at pressures
ranging from 280 to 750 psig.
(0066} In accordance with methods provided herein, aa alkyl aromatic
compound is provided to at least one reactor, Alkyl aromatic compounds
include aromatic hydrocarbons having at least one oxidi^able substituent
group capable of being oxidized to a corresponding carboxylic acid or the
derivative product. Preferred alkyl aromatic compounds include dieubstituted
benzene materials having any of a variety of eubstituents, such as alkyl,
bydroxyalkyl, aldehyde, carboalkyl groups, and mixtures thereof. More
pjf&ferred aikyi aromatic compounds include para-disubstxtuted benzene
derivatives having alkyl groups as substituents. An especially preferred alkyl
aromatic compound is p-xylene and/or p-toluic acid.
[0067] Typically, an alkyl aromatic compound is provided to at least one
reactor in, an amount ranging from about 310kg/s to about lQlOkg/a,
(0068] In a preferred embodiment, the present methods are performed in
the presence of a solvent wherein, the produced aromatic carboxylic acid is
soluble, For example, such solvents include, but are not limited to, p-xylene;
basic solvents such as chloro-benzene, morpholine, esters of carboxylic acids
and the like; carboxylic anhydrides; and acidic solvents, such as acetic acid.
[0069] Particularly preferred solvents are those which are the same as the
alkyl aromatic compound. For instance, in embodiments drawn to methods for

WO 20O6/O6847! t, PCT/NL2905/000876
22
preparing TPA, it is preferred that both the solvent and the alkyl aromatic
compound is p-xylene containing from 0 to 18 percent hy weight water. In
other embodiments drawn to methods for preparing TPA, it is preferred to use
a solvent in which, both terephthalic acid and th© intermediate 4-CBA is
soluble. Not wishing to be bound by any particular theory, it is believed that
keeping 4-CBA in solution, further oxidation of 4-CBA is facilitated. As a
consequence, a larger portion of 4-CBA within the reaction medium is
converted to terephthalic acid thereby decreasing the formation of color-
precursors. Moreover, the present process circumvents the need for removing
4-CBA from within the solid product precipitate in the reaction medium and
allows a one-step preparation of TPA.
[0070] Typically, solvent is provided to at least one reactor at a rate ranging
from about 310 kg/e to 1010 kg/s,
[0071] Itt accordance with methods provided herein, at least one invention
catalyst is provided to at least one reactor. For instance, an invention catalyst
can be provided to each reactor as an entrained slurry, a fluidissed bed, or
installed in various forms of fixed beds, membranes, packing arrangements,
etc. in each reactor within a series of reactors. The catalytic principle may be
provided alone, or as embedded zeolite crystallites within an inert matrix.
Typically, an invention catalyst is provided to at least one reactor in an
amount ranging from about 700 per 100 weight parts of p-xylene to 1400 per
100 weight parts of p-xylene (in matrix encapsulated form). Oxidation of alkyl
aromatic compounds in, the presence of an invention catalyst can occur for a
time period ranging from about 8 to about 20 mm
[0072] The reaction rate of oxidation methods presented herein are
enhanced by the addition of a halogen containing or releasing agent.
Preferable halogen, containing agents include hydrocarbyl bromated agents,
such as S-bromoanthracene and 9, 10-dibroraoanthracene. A halogen

WO 2006/068471 PCT/M-200S/000876
23
containing or releasing agent may be added to at least one reactor, such as to
each reactor within a series of reactors. In addition, the same or a different
halogen containing or releasing agent may be added to each reactor within a
series of reactors. Typically, halogen containing ox releasing agent is provided
to at least one reactor in such an amount that the bromine contents ranges
from about 2 to 4.5 weight parts of bromine per 100 weight parts of p-xylene.
[0073) In accordance with methods provided herein, an oxygen source is
provided to at least one reactor. For instance, an oxygen source can be
provided to each reactor within a series of reactors. Preferred oxygen source
include gaseous Og having a purity of at least 9o%. Typically, an oxygen
source is provided to at least one reactor in an amount ranging from about 10
to 15 kg oxygen per ton of reaction mixture.
[0074] Embodiments of methods herein include addition of a minute
amounts of zirconium and/or cerium and/or nickel and/or hafnium and/or
molybdenum and/or copper and/or zink containing catalytic principles to at
least one reactor. The effect of such metallic additions is discussed, for
example, in Partenheimer, "The effect of zirconium in metal/bromide catalysts
during the autoxidation of p-xylene, Part I. Activation and changes m
benzaldehyde intermediate formation," Journal of Molecular Catalysis A:
Chemical, Vol. 206: p. 105-119, (2003); and Partenheimer, "The effect of
zirconium in metal/bromide catalysts during the autoxidation of p-xylene, Part
II. Alternative metals to zirconium and the effect of zirconium on manganese
(IV) dioxide formation and precipitation with pyromellitic acid," Journal of
Molecular Catalysis A: Chemical, Vol. 206: p. 131-144, (2003), the entire
contents of both of which are incorporated herein by reference. Not wishing to
be bound by any particular theory, it is believed that inclusion of zirconium
and/or cerium into the catalyst enhances the reaction rate by providing a
parallel path to the deactivaiion of the Co(III) exited state.

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NU0O5/0O0876
24
EXAMPLES
[007S} The following examples are provided to further illustrate aspects of
the invention. These examples are non-limiting and should not be construed
as limiting any aspect of the invention.
EXAMPLE 1
Synthesis of Representative Invention Catalysts
[0O76| The foilotving exemplary procedure provides a representative method
to prepare invention catalysts. In addition to the procedures described herein,
numerous other procedures may be employed by one skilled in the art to
prepare intermediates for and assembling the invention catalyst, including
those described, for example, in Kennet J. et al. ("Applicable Zeolite
Encapsulation Methods Flexible Lif and Method", J. Indus. Phenom., Vol.
21:159-184 (1995)); Vandermade, A. W. et al, (J. Chem. Soc. Chera. Commun.,
Vol. 1204 (1983)); and Viswanathan et al. (J. Energy Heat and Mass Transfer,
Vol. 8: 281 (1996)). The beta zeolite can be synthesized using a number of
methods such as a dry gel conversion technique described, for example, in P.R.
Hari Prasada Eao et al. (Chem. Comraun. 1441 (1996)) and the modified
aerogel protocol patent (WO 2004/050555).
[0077] The following example procedure is adapted for synthesis of the
present catalyst from R.L. Wadlinger et al, US Patent 3308069, 1987, The
multi-step preparation uses an in situ synthesis of beta zeolite by
hydrothermai synthesis; the flexible Ugand exchange method is used for
incorporation of small h'gands into zeolites. Step 1 involves the synthesis of an
appropriate beta zeolite and calcinations to remove any organic structure
directing agents to create the catalyst scaffold. In step 2 the zeolite is
encapsulated in a matrix material (SiO2 in the example). Step 3 involves
absorption, of Co(Il) and Mn(II) onto the suitably acidic zeolite. After

WO 2006/068471 , PCT.NUftOS/000876
25
subsequent ion'exchange with the metals, the resultant metal-loaded -
composite is dried. Step 4 involves coordination of the metal with nitrogen
containing acids and increasing the oxidation, state of the metals by oxygen
addition to prepare the appropriate metal complex of the catalytic principle.
This is followed by drying of the catalyst.
jgtep 1. Synthe8i3jQf.bjgta_zeojite
An amount of 39.3 g (0.654 mol) of S1O2 silica gel. Cab-o-sil M-5 slowly added to
171.3 % (0.407 mol) of tetraethylamraonium hydroxide (TEAOH) 35 wt. % in
HaO, while stirring; a white gel is obtained.
A solution of 4.89 g (5.97102mol) of NaAlOa dissolved in 69.3 ml of deionised
H2O is added to the gel while stirring and manually mixing: a thicker gel is
obtained.
Upon mixing and aging, the gel becomes more fluid.
The gel is stirred for 2 hours and then transferred into teflon-lined stainless-
steel autoclaves. The autoclaves are closed and heated statically to 150°C in an
oven.
After 6 days at 150°C, the autoclaves axe removed from the oven and allowed
to cool down to room temperature.
The autoclaves contain a white-yellow gel-like precipitate and a surnatant
solution. The precipitate is separated from the surnatant by centrifugation.
Next, it is washed repeatedly with HsO and centrifuged until the washing has
a pH The whits sample is dried in an oven at 11G°C for 12 hours: 29.150 g of a white
fine powder are obtained.

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/000876
26
[0078] Powder XRD shows that the white powder is highly crystalline pure
zeolite beta.
[0079] Sample characterised by; SBM, BDX and ICP-OES elemental
analyses.
Si/Al = 8.3, Na/Al = 0,22 (BDX).
Si/Al - 8,8, Na/Al = 0.20 (ICP-OES),
[0080] Crystals of primary particles with a diameter of -20-40 nm (from
XRP and SEM data). Aggregates of primary particles with a diameter of-200-
300 ran.
Step 2. Inclusion of zeolite beta particlgsJn&La TUD-1 matr.bc
[0081J The preparation is an adaptation of the procedure outlined in. P.
Waller et al., Ghem. Eur, J.5 2004, 10, 4970.
16 g of zeolite beta (see paragraph 1) are suspended in 6.8 g (0.116 nxol) of
NH«0H in H2O (NHs ACSreagent, 28-30 wt. % NHs in H2O) and in 40.65 g of
deionised H2O while vigorously stirring: a white suspension is obtained.
30.45 g (0.2 raol) of triethanolamine (98%) are mixed with 25.00 g of deionised
H2O and then added to the white suspension while vigorously stirring.
84,92 g (0.4 mol) of tetraethyl orthosilicate (TEOS, 98%) are added dropwise
(10 g /rain) while vigorously stirring. After stirring for ^1 hour, a gel is formed.
16.83 g (0.04 mol) of TEAOH 35 wt. % in HzO are added dropwise while
vigorously stirring: the gel thickens until the magnetic stirring becomes
ineffective.

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NUfH)5/O0O$7
23
[0086] 0.252 g of Co(CH3CO2)2 4H20 (1.01 -10-3 mol, Co/Al = 0.06)
dissolved in 50 ml deionised H2O: the pink solution is added to the suspension
while stirring.
The stirred suspension is heated to 60°O for 12 hours (in a water bath), then at
room temperature for 4 hours. The pink solid is separated by vacuum filtration
and washed repeatedly with deionised HgO.
The pick solid is suspended in 325 ml CH3CO2H (glacial) by stirring.
(00871 0414 g of Mn(CH3CO2)2 >4H2O (1.69 -10-3 moi, Mn/Al = 0.10)
dissolved in 325 ml CH3CO2H (glacial) by stirring: the solution is added to the
suspension while stirring.
The atirred suspension is heated to 60°C for 12 hours (in a water bath), then at
room temperature for 4 hours. The solid is separated by vacuum filtration and
washed with 700 ml of a 1:1 solution of acetic acid and deionieed HgO.
The off-white wet powder is dried in an oven at 120°C for 2 days: 84.59g of
sample are obtained.
[0088J ICP-OES analysis:
Co/Al = 0.045 (efficiency of cobalt exchange: 74%).
Co weight %: 0.111%.
Mn/AJ. = 0.079 (efficiency of manganese exchange: 79%).
Mn weight %: 0.184%.
Mn/Co = 1.778 (the target was Mn/Co ~ 2).

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NU005/000876
29
IK analysis does not show any change after the Co and Mn exchange.
Step 4... Coordination of Metal-Exchanged Zeolites with.Nittsgeajtods
[0089] A sample containing 0.5 g of a Co and Mn exchanged zeolite beta s
(see step 3) containing 2.04 -1(M mol of Co + Mn was used.
6,0 ICH mol of NaOH (0.24 g) were dissolved in 4 g of deionised HzG. 5,010*8
mol of nicotinic acid (0.62 g) were added to the aqueous solution and dissolved
by stirring. Next, 4,08-10"3 mol (i-e. 2 moles per mole of metal, as in the
complexes) of acetic acid (0,025 g) were added while stirring. A colourless
transparent solution with pH ~11 was obtained.
The aqueous solution was added to the 0.5 g of zeolite sampk while stimng: a
light brown suspension was obtained.
2,0 10'3 niol of HgOj were added as 0.060 g of a solution, obtained by mixing
6.150 g of HgOa 35 wt.% aqueous solution with 0.314 g of deionised HsO:
bubbles evolved and the brown colour of the suspension becomes darker.
(0090) After stirring for 1 hour, 2.5 10-4 mol of NaBr (0.026 g) previously-
dissolved in 0-5 g of deionised H2O were added to the suspension while
stirring.
After stirring for 30 minutes, the suspension was filtered under vacuum on a
Buchner filter and washed with 100 ml of a 1:1 (in volume) solution of ethanol
and acetic acid.
[0O9ij The solid residue was dried overnight in an oven at 110eC: 0.44 g of a
light grey powder were obtained.

WO 2006/068471 PCl7NL2O05/OOO87 30
EXAMPLE 2
Exemplary Procedure for Preparation of Representative Aromatic
Carboxylic Acid
(0092] A preferred embodiment for the production of terephthalic acid is
illustrated in FIG. 1.
[0093] Invention methods provided the following advantageous properties
due, in part, to the low conversion of para-xylene in the oxidation reactor.
• The temperature increase of the reaction mixture is sufficient to
dissipate the heat of reaction and thus, there is no need to cool the
oxidation reactor.
• The oxygen applied to the oxidation reactor is dissolved and does not
form a separate vapor phase.
• The water produced by the chemical reaction will not form a separate
liquid phase.
• The terephthalic acid produced by the chemical reactioa will not form a
separate solid phase.
Reactors
[0094] Oxidation of p-xylene is performed in continuous oxidation reactors,
conceived in such a way to avoid back-mixing, wherein each reactor is fed with
an oxygen source. Reactors containing fiuidized beds with intrinsic recycle of
catalyst, fixed beds with static arrangement of catalyst, or cross flow beds and
membrane reactors may also be used. As exemplified in Figure 1, the
oxidation resctor may be composed of one of several reaction vessels.

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL20O5/0O0R76
31
Qxidatioa JEfeggtjpja..
[0095] As shown in Figure 1, an oxygen source and p-xylene is fed into the
oxidation reactor. Terephthaiic acid (TPA), produced in the oxidation reaction,
remains soluble in p-xylen© throughout the course of the oxidation reaction.
Thus, the oxidation reaction mixture is essentially a single-phase liquid
mixture. Operating conditions ixx the oxidation, reactor are such that no second
phase will be formed, neither as a vapor, liquid, or solid.
[0096] Invention catalysis, which remain solid suspended in p-xylene, may
be added to the oxidation reactor in the form of a slurry that leaves the reactor
with the reaction mixture or can be arranged in various forms such as fixed
bed, radial bed, membranes and the like,
{00971 The reaction mixture is de-pressurized over a throttle valve after
leaving the oxidation, reactor.
^■Pjatatio.tu?iJny.e.atipn_C.ataly.s.t
[0098] The solid invention catalyst used in the oxidation reaction, when
used in a slurry or fluidi^ed bed configuration, is separated (e.g., by a
hydrocyckme) prior to separation of the reaction products from the reaction
mixture. After separation, invention catalysts are rinsed with fresh p-xylene,
recycled dry p-xylene or a combination of such streams in a eountercurrent
wash. Invention catalyst may then be recycled as a slurry back into the
oxidation reactor for continuous oxidation reactions, along with the balance
make-up of p-xylene and the bulk of th© recycled solvent.
[0099] la embodiments where the catalyst contacts the reaction mixture in
the form of a fixed ox fluidized bed, the catalyst will not leave the oxidation
reactor. As such, separation of the catalyst from the reaction mixture is not
necessary.

WO 200f-/068471 , , PCT/NL20D5/000876
32
Pr.es.surizatio.n Decreases
[00100J During de-pressurization. the reaction mixture will start to boil and
as a result the temperature of both the vapor phase and the liquid phase will
start to decrease. As a result of the boiling, water, gaseous components, and p-
jtylene from the oxidation reactor will vaporize, leaving behind the produced
terephthaiic acid in a solid form.
Removal of Reaction, Impurities
[00101] As shown in Figure 1, water created by the oxidation reaction is
removed from the remaining solvent stream (containing p-xylene, water and
residual impurities) hy distillation or sequential flashing, during which the
volatile side products axe also removed, Non-volatilee may be removed as a
purge side stream from the bottom of the separation stage, to be processed
separately to remove heavy components and prevent build-up in the reactor.
Crystallization of Terephthaiic Acid
{001021 The catalyst-free main stream is cooled after catalyst separation,
leading to crystallization of terephthaiic acid. Crystals are recovered (e.g., by a
hydrocyclone or filtration) from the solvent and processed fox subsequent use
by countercurrent washing with fresh p-xylene.
QontirAij&usJifecyclinsi into_Qxidation Reactors
I00103J The "dry*' p-xyieno, together witk severed other p-xylene recuperation
Streams (e.g. decaatation from a flash or distillation top fraction the catafyst

WO 2006/068471 PCT/NL2005/000876
33
washing, etc.) are fed back into the recycle solvent stream to the oxidation
reactor. This recycled solvent may be split in several washing streams (such
as for rinsing the recovered terephthalic acid crystals, the recovered catalyst,
etc.) but these streams of p-xyiene are eventually collected, and fed to the
oxidation reactor directly or to prepare the slurry for the recycled catalyst- To
the combined recycle the make-up for the catalyst and the bromine containing
component is also added.

WO 200f>/0(>8471 PCT/NL2003/OW876
34

WE CLAIM:
1. A catalyst system based on zeolite crystallites attached to support or
incorporated in a matrix and a catalytically active compound incorporated
in the zeolite, the said crystallites having a diameter or between 20 and
300 nm and said catalytically active component having a formula selected
from:
CoMn2(O)(R-COO)6 L1k1 L2k2 wherein :
R is an optionally substituted C1-C4 alkyl;
L1 is an optionally substituted nitrogen containing carboxylic acid
or carboxylate;
L2 is selected from the group consisting of H2O, an optionally
substituted C1-C4 alkyl containing carboxylic acid, an
optionally substituted C5-C6 cycloalkyl or heterocycle, an
optionally substituted C5-C6 heteroaryl or aryl; and
k1+k2 = 3;
wherein the zeolite has an Si/AI atomic ratio of at least 8.

2. The catalyst system as claimed in claim 1, wherein R of said catalytic
compound is -CH3 or -C2H5.
3. The catalyst system as claimed in claim 1 or 2, wherein L1 of said catalytic
compound is selected from the group consisting of picolinic acid, nicotinic
acid, and i-nicotinic acid, or salt thereof and independently of the selection
of L1,L2 is CH3COOH or H2O.
4. A catalyst system based on zeolite crystallites attached to support or
incorporated in a matrix and a catalytically active principle incorporated in
the zeolite, the said crystallites having a diameter or between 20 and 300
nm and said catalytically active compound having a formula selected from:
CoMn2(O)(R-COO)6-k3 L3k3 L4k4 wherein
R is an optionally substituted C1-C4 alkyl;
L3 is an optionally substituted nitrogen containing carboxylate;
L4 is selected from the group consisting of H2O, an optionally
substituted nitrogen containing carboxylic acid, an optionally
substituted C1-C4 alkyl containing carboxylic acid, an
optionally substituted C5-C6 cycloalkyl or heterocycle, and an
optionally substituted C5-C6 heteroaryl or aryl;

k3 is 1,2, or 3;
k3 + k4 = 3
5. The catalyst system as claimed in claim 1-4, wherein said zeolite belongs
to the class MEI or beta (*BEA) but also including members of the
associated disorder families, such as fibrous and the like, and micro-
porous structures based on the above zeolites and mixtures thereof.
6. Catalysts based on the catalyst system of claim 1-5, with crystallites of
zeolite embedded, grafted or encapsulated in meso-porous matrix
including SiO2 and/or carbon.

A catalyst system based on zeolite crystallites attached to support or
incorporated in a matrix and a catalytically active compound incorporated in the
zeolite, the said crystallites having a diameter or between 20 and 300 nm and
said catalytically active component having a formula selected from:
CoMn2(O)(R-COO)6 L1k1 L2k2 wherein :
R is an optionally substituted C1-C4 alkyl;
L1 is an optionally substituted nitrogen containing carboxylic acid
or carboxylate;
L2 is selected from the group consisting of H2O, an optionally
substituted C1-C4 alkyl containing carboxylic acid, an
optionally substituted C5-C6 cycloalkyl or heterocycle, an
optionally substituted C5-C6 heteroaryl or aryl; and
k1+k2 = 3;
wherein the zeolite has an Si/AI atomic ratio of at least 8.

Documents:

02399-kolnp-2007-abstract.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-claims.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-correspondence others 1.1.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-correspondence others 1.2.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-correspondence others.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-description complete.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-drawings.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-form 1 1.1.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-form 1.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-form 2.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-form 3.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-form 5.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-international publication.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-international search report.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-pct request form 1.1.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-pct request form.pdf

02399-kolnp-2007-priority document.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-(15-09-2011)-ABSTRACT.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-(15-09-2011)-AMANDED CLAIMS.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-(15-09-2011)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-(15-09-2011)-DESCRIPTION (COMPLETE).pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-(15-09-2011)-FORM 1.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-(15-09-2011)-FORM 2.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-(15-09-2011)-OTHERS.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-(19-04-2012)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-(27-04-2012)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-(27-04-2012)-FORM-3.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-(27-04-2012)-PETITION UNDER RULE 137.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-ABSTRACT.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-AMANDED CLAIMS.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-CORRESPONDENCE OTHERS 1.3.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-CORRESPONDENCE-1.3.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-CORRESPONDENCE.1.4.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-DESCRIPTION (COMPLETE).pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-EXAMINATION REPORT REPLY RECIEVED.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-EXAMINATION REPORT.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-FORM 1-1.2.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-FORM 18 1.1.pdf

2399-kolnp-2007-form 18.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-FORM 2.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-FORM 26 1.1.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-FORM 26.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-FORM 3.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-FORM 5.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-GRANTED-ABSTRACT.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-GRANTED-CLAIMS.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-GRANTED-DESCRIPTION (COMPLETE).pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-GRANTED-DRAWINGS.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-GRANTED-FORM 1.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-GRANTED-FORM 2.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-GRANTED-SPECIFICATION.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-OTHERS.pdf

2399-KOLNP-2007-REPLY TO EXAMINATION REPORT 1.1.pdf


Patent Number 251962
Indian Patent Application Number 2399/KOLNP/2007
PG Journal Number 16/2012
Publication Date 20-Apr-2012
Grant Date 18-Apr-2012
Date of Filing 29-Jun-2007
Name of Patentee PROCESS DESIGN CENTER B.V.
Applicant Address CATHARINASTRAAT 21 F, 4811 XD BREDA
Inventors:
# Inventor's Name Inventor's Address
1 DE MEYER, HERMAN, JOZEF, CLAUDIUS MIKSEBEEKSTRAAT 19, B-2930 BRASSCHAAT
2 SIJBEN, JOHANNES, MARIA, FRANCISCUS HOGE NEERSTRAAT 6, NO-4873 LM ETTEN-LEUR
PCT International Classification Number B01J 29/16
PCT International Application Number PCT/NL2005/000876
PCT International Filing date 2005-12-20
PCT Conventions:
# PCT Application Number Date of Convention Priority Country
1 60/654,986 2005-02-22 U.S.A.
2 60/638,021 2004-12-20 U.S.A.